Best Items Logo
Products are independently selected by our editors. If you buy through our links, we may earn a commission.
Back to Reviews

Apple AirTag 4-Pack vs. Life360 Tile Mate: Which Tracker for Holiday Luggage and Keys?

By Best Items Staff
A wintry front-hall scene the morning before holiday travel with nobody in frame: a gray hard-shell carry-on and a dark duffel on a wooden bench, a key ring with a small round silver tracker disc hanging on a wall hook beside a wool scarf and coat, another round tracker clipped to the duffel's zipper pull, a passport and boarding pass on the bench, soft cool light through the door glass, candid editorial

Between the checked bag, the carry-on, the backpack, and the house keys you hand to a neighbor, holiday travel gives a lot of things a chance to go missing. A small Bluetooth tracker won't prevent that, but it can turn a long, stressful search into a quick one. The real question is which tracker, and the answer mostly comes down to the phone in your pocket. Here's how the Apple AirTag (2nd Generation) 4-Pack and the Life360 Tile Mate compare.

Apple AirTag (2nd Generation) 4-Pack

Apple AirTag (2nd Generation) 4-Pack, Item Tracker with Find My, Precision Finding on iPhone and Apple Watch works with the Find My app to help you keep track of keys, bags, wallets, and luggage. Per its product page, upgraded Ultra Wideband and Bluetooth chips extend the finding range, Precision Finding guides you to your item on iPhone and Apple Watch, and a louder speaker with a new chime makes it easier to hear. You can also share an item's location temporarily with trusted contacts or airline partners, and the replaceable battery lasts more than a year. Catalog rating: 4.6 / 5.0.

The four-pack is the one to look at if you're tagging a whole trip: two checked bags, a carry-on, and a key ring, for example. Prices on the site update daily, so check the product page for the current price.

Life360 Tile Mate

Life360 Tile Mate Bluetooth Tracker, 1-Pack Black is a compact tracker that attaches to keys, bags, or luggage. Per its product page, you can ring it from the Life360 app within about 350 feet, it works on both iOS and Android, it doubles as a phone finder, and it includes SOS alerts for family safety. Catalog rating: 4.5 / 5.0. Range indoors is shorter than it sounds, since walls and floors reduce Bluetooth range, so treat the figure as an open-air best case.

How they compare

Phone support: this is the deciding factor. The AirTag is built around Apple's Find My, so it's best for people with an iPhone. The Tile Mate works on iOS and Android, which makes it the better pick for an Android household or a family where phones are mixed. Finding up close: AirTag's Precision Finding guides you to the item on an iPhone or Apple Watch, while the Tile Mate rings from the app. Sharing with an airline: the AirTag lets you share an item's location temporarily with trusted contacts or airline partners. Quantity: the AirTag comes as a four-pack here and the Tile Mate as a single, so tagging several bags is simpler with the multipack.

Our take: if everyone you travel with has an iPhone, start with the AirTag 4-Pack. If anyone relies on Android, or you want something that works on either, the Tile Mate is the more flexible choice.

If you only need one: the AirTag 1-Pack

Not everyone has four things to track. Apple AirTag (2nd Generation) 1-Pack is the same second-generation tracker in a single unit, with the louder alert, longer Precision Finding range, and replaceable battery described on its product page. It clips onto a suitcase, backpack, or key ring, though some bags need a separate loop or holder to attach it cleanly. Like the 4-pack, it works best with an iPhone and Find My. Catalog rating: 4.5 / 5.0.

Using a tracker well on a trip

Put the tracker inside the bag or in an interior pocket, not hanging off the outside where it's easy to remove. Test it at home before you leave so you know how it rings and where it shows up in the app. Keep your name and phone number on a luggage tag as well, since a tracker is a Bluetooth device and not a GPS unit, and it relies on nearby phones to report its location. It also doesn't replace the airline's baggage process, so report a missing bag to the airline right away and use the tracker's location as extra information. Use trackers only on your own belongings.

Who should skip them

A Bluetooth tracker isn't a pet or vehicle GPS device. The Tile Mate's product page says it's for nearby items, and pets or cars usually need a purpose-built GPS tracker with a safe way to attach it. If you rarely lose anything and don't travel much, a single tracker on your keys is plenty.

The bottom line

Pick by phone. The Apple AirTag 4-Pack is the value-minded choice for iPhone families who want to tag keys and several bags, the AirTag 1-Pack covers a single item, and the Life360 Tile Mate is the cross-platform option when Android is in the mix. Check each product page for the current price.